When your meals courtroom’s declare to fame is a scorching canine that has its private Wikipedia internet web page and a value that hasn’t elevated since 1984, any modifications to the restricted menu are newsworthy. Significantly when considered one of many fan-favorite devices that has been spherical given that ‘90s—the Costco churro—was these days modified by the warehouse massive’s new double chocolate chunk cookie.
Needing to restock my paper towels and fizzy water this week, I used that as a ruse to drive to my nearest Costco and take a look at the buzzworthy cookie. Controversy doesn’t always make a meals model greater, nonetheless as a former bakery proprietor I don’t need numerous an excuse to scrutinize baked objects.
After wandering the aisles and grabbing the few devices I needed, plus a pair points I utterly did not, I made my technique to the meals courtroom, which was full of parents and their full buying carts. I forked over $2.50 in cash and was handed a warmth, heavy chocolate chunk cookie in a crinkly brown paper sleeve. Whereas the first few bites had been fairly, this cookie gained’t be part of my month-to-month Costco routine.
The Cookie Controversy
The first sticking elements behind the cookie complaints I’ve study are the worth and the vitamin content material materials. For many who consider the model new $2.49 cookie to completely different Costco menu devices, it does look like on the extreme end. You probably can, in any case, get a hen bake, which is a complete meal, for $3.99. Nonetheless in a world the place enough people pay $3.99 for a Crumbl chocolate chip cookie that the chain has over 900 locations, the Costco cookie’s price tag doesn’t seem so outrageous.
As for its 750-calorie vitamin profile, I am going to grant you that this amount is spectacular. Nonetheless I’m far more impressed by Costco’s chilly brew mocha freeze, which someway manages to incorporate 580 power. The cookie is full of delicious butter and chocolate. What’s your excuse, chilly brew mocha freeze?
Nonetheless How Does it Fashion?
The very very first thing to know regarding the Costco cookie is that it is a warmth cookie, so my thoughts lit up on the model of brown butter and molten chocolate. It’s not underbaked, which is a few extent in its favor for these of us who like a bit of little bit of coloration on our cookies, and the skin is a little bit of crusty, yielding to a mild crumb that doesn’t scrimp on the chocolate chunks. The first couple of bites are distinctive, in the easiest way that the first couple bites of all warmth cookies are distinctive.
The Spruce Eats / Megan Scott
After that, there have been diminishing returns. The cookie is great sweet and loaded down with chocolate bits. I gained’t say it’s an extreme quantity of chocolate, nonetheless it’s enough that you just need a tall glass of 1 factor to take care of it from sticking inside the throat. And, maybe that’s merely the Millennial in me, nonetheless I wanted nothing better than to liberally mud Maldon salt in every single place within the cookie. All that sweetness is crying out for salt.
The Spruce Eats / Megan Scott
My confederate and I ate half the cookie, nonetheless as a result of it started to relax down (this happens shortly) the attraction wore off, and we ended up not ending it. I can see why some Costco prospects downed the cookie in 5 minutes attempting to beat the quick cooling, which then resulted in a stomach ache. Then once more, some prospects are going for a double-down second and sandwiching two cookies with the meals courtroom mild serve, so know thyself I suppose.
I don’t have any regrets. For $2.50 I obtained to eat just some bites of a warmth chocolate chunk cookie on a cold day. Nonetheless as quickly as is enough for me, and solely time will inform whether or not or not this meals courtroom upstart may have the endurance of the churro (RIP).